Skip to content
Manual and electric pallet trucks compared

Manual vs electric pallet trucks: which pallet truck pays off?

4.9/5· 66 reviews

Interested in a quick quote?


Manual pallet trucks: pros and cons

Advantages:

Because of their comparatively lower cost, manual pallet trucks are widely used throughout the logistics industry.

Manual pallet trucks need comparatively little maintenance and have no electrical components. A simpler design means repairs are often quicker than on electric pallet trucks, and spare parts are usually easy to obtain.

Manual pallet trucks are known for being reliable and very durable. Their sturdy, hard-wearing designs make long-term maintenance easier, and they can usually withstand the rigours of a busy facility.

In terms of design, manual pallet trucks can move very heavy loads smoothly, so pallets are not damaged in transit.

Manual pallet trucks benefit from a basic design that suits many types of pallet. They are highly adaptable, so they can be used in operations of any scale. They can also be bought with different fork dimensions to better suit applications that call for different sizes.

Disadvantages:

With manual pallet trucks, the loads can strain the operator and cause injuries.

By their nature, manual pallet trucks can be more cumbersome to operate.

Because there is a limit to how much weight one person can move unaided, a worker may not be able to move the truck alone: manual pallet trucks are not easy to manoeuvre when loaded close to their rated capacity, e.g. 2,500 kg. (Note: for safety reasons, it is recommended never to load a manual pallet truck even close to its capacity.)

Manual and electric pallet trucks compared

Electric pallet trucks: pros and cons

Advantages:

Because they are powered and include assisted lifting, electric pallet trucks are less likely to cause injury to the operator.

Electric pallet trucks come in light-, medium- and heavy-duty categories. Whatever your workload, there is an electric pallet truck that will meet your company's needs.

An integrated power system allows electric pallet trucks to lift, lower and travel around a warehouse.

In a busy warehouse, electric pallet trucks can save many working hours, allowing staff to cover longer distances with fewer breaks.

Aiolos Lifts semi-electric pallet truck

Disadvantages:

An electric pallet truck tends to cost more than a manual version, although the cost can be offset over time, as electric pallet trucks can raise a warehouse's overall productivity.

Electric pallet trucks can have more maintenance issues. With electrical components, parts will eventually need repairing, and because repairs are more complex, maintenance can be more demanding, costly and time-consuming.

Since electric models are built to move taller and heavier stacks of pallets, having to stop work completely, even for a short time, to charge the machine can be a challenge.

As with any powered equipment in a materials handling facility, an electric pallet truck will require additional operator training.

To decide which option suits a particular type of materials handling operation or facility, weigh up all of the factors above to find the best pallet truck solution for your site.

See them in action

Videos from the manufacturer's (STAXX) official YouTube channel.

About choosing a manual or an electric pallet truck

Every business has different pallet truck needs. Some managers prioritise speed, flexibility, load capacity or ease of use, while others prefer a truck that will outlast the rest and potentially save on maintenance or replacement costs. Fortunately, there are plenty of options when choosing a pallet truck – one of which is whether to use a manual or an electric pallet truck.

Which factors should you consider?

Comparing a manual pallet truck with an electric one is not always straightforward. After all, every facility and every company is different. Before deciding which option to use, consider the following factors.

How large is your facility? As a general rule, larger facilities will call for electric pallet trucks. For example, moving pallets by hand over long distances can be physically exhausting for a worker. Conversely, in more confined spaces an electric pallet truck may not be the best choice, as manoeuvring in a tight space can be a little more difficult than with a manual option.

What are your pallet stacking needs? Electric pallet handling machines are usually better designed for easily lifting and moving tall stacks of pallets.

Would you rather save money now or later? Electric pallet trucks are an investment and may not pay off in the first few years of a new business. You need to take into account staffing costs, the potential cost of complex maintenance and the cost of breakdowns on a more expensive machine. You should also consider the potential liability of having more electrical equipment on your premises.

Latest news

Choose the manual or electric pallet truck that suits you!

Manual pallet trucks

Manual pallet truck

Manual pallet trucks

Weighing manual pallet truck

Manual weighing pallet trucks

Galvanised manual pallet truck

Manual galvanised pallet trucks

Scissor manual pallet truck

Manual scissor pallet trucks

Electric pallet trucks for warehouses & lorries

Aiolos Lifts semi-electric pallet truck

Electric pallet trucks

Weighing semi-electric pallet truck

Semi-electric weighing pallet trucks

Aiolos Lifts electric pallet truck

Semi-electric pallet trucks

Electric pallet truck with GEL battery

GEL-battery electric pallet trucks

Pallet stackers

Electric pallet stacker

Electric pallet stackers

Semi-electric pallet stacker

Semi-electric pallet stackers

Manual pallet stacker

Manual pallet stackers